cacert/cacert-webdb
9
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull requests 3 Projects Releases 4 Wiki Activity

Fix for https://bugs.cacert.org/view.php?id=918

Browse source 
(detection and prevention of weak keys for CAcert-issued certificates)
This commit is contained in:
Wytze van der Raay 2011-06-16 09:19:58 +00:00
parent bd0a4c0023
commit 8571e6f0a9
2 changed files with 498 additions and 16 deletions
Show stats Download patch file Download diff file Expand all files Collapse all files

157
includes/account.php
View file

@ -299,6 +299,15 @@
$_SESSION['_config']['rootcert'] = 1; $_SESSION['_config']['rootcert'] = 1;
$emails .= "SPKAC = $spkac"; $emails .= "SPKAC = $spkac";
if (($weakKey = checkWeakKeySPKAC($emails)) !== "")
{
$id = 4;
showheader(_("My CAcert.org Account!"));
echo $weakKey;
showfooter();
exit;
}
$query = "insert into emailcerts set $query = "insert into emailcerts set
`CN`='$defaultemail', `CN`='$defaultemail',
`keytype`='NS', `keytype`='NS',
@ -330,6 +339,16 @@
} else if($_REQUEST['keytype'] == "MS" || $_REQUEST['keytype'] == "VI") { } else if($_REQUEST['keytype'] == "MS" || $_REQUEST['keytype'] == "VI") {
if($csr == "") if($csr == "")
$csr = "-----BEGIN CERTIFICATE REQUEST-----\n".clean_csr($_REQUEST['CSR'])."\n-----END CERTIFICATE REQUEST-----\n"; $csr = "-----BEGIN CERTIFICATE REQUEST-----\n".clean_csr($_REQUEST['CSR'])."\n-----END CERTIFICATE REQUEST-----\n";
if (($weakKey = checkWeakKeyCSR($csr)) !== "")
{
$id = 4;
showheader(_("My CAcert.org Account!"));
echo $weakKey;
showfooter();
exit;
}
$tmpfname = tempnam("/tmp", "id4CSR"); $tmpfname = tempnam("/tmp", "id4CSR");
$fp = fopen($tmpfname, "w"); $fp = fopen($tmpfname, "w");
fputs($fp, $csr); fputs($fp, $csr);
@ -613,17 +632,23 @@
if($process != "" && $oldid == 10) if($process != "" && $oldid == 10)
{ {
$CSR = clean_csr($_REQUEST['CSR']); $CSR = clean_csr($_REQUEST['CSR']);
$_SESSION['_config']['tmpfname'] = tempnam("/tmp", "id10CSR");
$fp = fopen($_SESSION['_config']['tmpfname'], "w");
if(strpos($CSR,"---BEGIN")===FALSE) if(strpos($CSR,"---BEGIN")===FALSE)
{ {
// In case the CSR is missing the ---BEGIN lines, add them automatically: // In case the CSR is missing the ---BEGIN lines, add them automatically:
fputs($fp,"-----BEGIN CERTIFICATE REQUEST-----\n".$CSR."\n-----END CERTIFICATE REQUEST-----\n"); $CSR = "-----BEGIN CERTIFICATE REQUEST-----\n".$CSR."\n-----END CERTIFICATE REQUEST-----\n";
} }
else
if (($weakKey = checkWeakKeyCSR($CSR)) !== "")
{ {
fputs($fp, $CSR); showheader(_("My CAcert.org Account!"));
echo $weakKey;
showfooter();
exit;
} }
$_SESSION['_config']['tmpfname'] = tempnam("/tmp", "id10CSR");
$fp = fopen($_SESSION['_config']['tmpfname'], "w");
fputs($fp, $CSR);
fclose($fp); fclose($fp);
$CSR = $_SESSION['_config']['tmpfname']; $CSR = $_SESSION['_config']['tmpfname'];
$_SESSION['_config']['subject'] = trim(`/usr/bin/openssl req -text -noout -in "$CSR"|tr -d "\\0"|grep "Subject:"`); $_SESSION['_config']['subject'] = trim(`/usr/bin/openssl req -text -noout -in "$CSR"|tr -d "\\0"|grep "Subject:"`);
@ -658,6 +683,23 @@
if($process != "" && $oldid == 11) if($process != "" && $oldid == 11)
{ {
if(!file_exists($_SESSION['_config']['tmpfname']))
{
showheader(_("My CAcert.org Account!"));
printf(_("Your certificate request has failed to be processed correctly, see %sthe WIKI page%s for reasons and solutions."), "<a href='http://wiki.cacert.org/wiki/FAQ/CertificateRenewal'>", "</a>");
showfooter();
exit;
}
if (($weakKey = checkWeakKeyCSR(file_get_contents(
$_SESSION['_config']['tmpfname']))) !== "")
{
showheader(_("My CAcert.org Account!"));
echo $weakKey;
showfooter();
exit;
}
$id = 11; $id = 11;
if($_SESSION['_config']['0.CN'] == "" && $_SESSION['_config']['0.subjectAltName'] == "") if($_SESSION['_config']['0.CN'] == "" && $_SESSION['_config']['0.subjectAltName'] == "")
{ {
@ -731,13 +773,6 @@
mysql_query("insert into `domlink` set `certid`='$CSRid', `domid`='$dom'"); mysql_query("insert into `domlink` set `certid`='$CSRid', `domid`='$dom'");
$CSRname=generatecertpath("csr","server",$CSRid); $CSRname=generatecertpath("csr","server",$CSRid);
if(!file_exists($_SESSION['_config']['tmpfname']))
{
showheader(_("My CAcert.org Account!"));
printf(_("Your certificate request has failed to be processed correctly, see %sthe WIKI page%s for reasons and solutions."), "<a href='http://wiki.cacert.org/wiki/FAQ/CertificateRenewal'>", "</a>");
showfooter();
exit;
}
rename($_SESSION['_config']['tmpfname'], $CSRname); rename($_SESSION['_config']['tmpfname'], $CSRname);
chmod($CSRname,0644); chmod($CSRname,0644);
mysql_query("update `domaincerts` set `CSR_name`='$CSRname' where `id`='$CSRid'"); mysql_query("update `domaincerts` set `CSR_name`='$CSRname' where `id`='$CSRid'");
@ -780,8 +815,17 @@
printf(_("Invalid ID '%s' presented, can't do anything with it.")."<br/>\n", $id); printf(_("Invalid ID '%s' presented, can't do anything with it.")."<br/>\n", $id);
continue; continue;
} }
mysql_query("update `domaincerts` set `renewed`='1' where `id`='$id'");
$row = mysql_fetch_assoc($res); $row = mysql_fetch_assoc($res);
if (($weakKey = checkWeakKeyX509(file_get_contents(
$row['crt_name']))) !== "")
{
echo $weakKey, "<br/>\n";
continue;
}
mysql_query("update `domaincerts` set `renewed`='1' where `id`='$id'");
$query = "insert into `domaincerts` set $query = "insert into `domaincerts` set
`domid`='".$row['domid']."', `domid`='".$row['domid']."',
`CN`='".mysql_real_escape_string($row['CN'])."', `CN`='".mysql_real_escape_string($row['CN'])."',
@ -946,8 +990,17 @@
printf(_("Invalid ID '%s' presented, can't do anything with it.")."<br>\n", $id); printf(_("Invalid ID '%s' presented, can't do anything with it.")."<br>\n", $id);
continue; continue;
} }
mysql_query("update `emailcerts` set `renewed`='1' where `id`='$id'");
$row = mysql_fetch_assoc($res); $row = mysql_fetch_assoc($res);
if (($weakKey = checkWeakKeyX509(file_get_contents(
$row['crt_name']))) !== "")
{
echo $weakKey, "<br/>\n";
continue;
}
mysql_query("update `emailcerts` set `renewed`='1' where `id`='$id'");
$query = "insert into emailcerts set $query = "insert into emailcerts set
`memid`='".$row['memid']."', `memid`='".$row['memid']."',
`CN`='".mysql_real_escape_string($row['CN'])."', `CN`='".mysql_real_escape_string($row['CN'])."',
@ -1378,6 +1431,15 @@
$_SESSION['_config']['rootcert'] = 1; $_SESSION['_config']['rootcert'] = 1;
$emails .= "SPKAC = $spkac"; $emails .= "SPKAC = $spkac";
if (($weakKey = checkWeakKeySPKAC($emails)) !== "")
{
$id = 17;
showheader(_("My CAcert.org Account!"));
echo $weakKey;
showfooter();
exit;
}
$query = "insert into `orgemailcerts` set $query = "insert into `orgemailcerts` set
`CN`='$defaultemail', `CN`='$defaultemail',
`keytype`='NS', `keytype`='NS',
@ -1408,6 +1470,16 @@
mysql_query("update `orgemailcerts` set `csr_name`='$CSRname' where `id`='$emailid'"); mysql_query("update `orgemailcerts` set `csr_name`='$CSRname' where `id`='$emailid'");
} else if($_REQUEST['keytype'] == "MS" || $_REQUEST['keytype']=="VI") { } else if($_REQUEST['keytype'] == "MS" || $_REQUEST['keytype']=="VI") {
$csr = "-----BEGIN CERTIFICATE REQUEST-----\n".clean_csr($_REQUEST['CSR'])."-----END CERTIFICATE REQUEST-----\n"; $csr = "-----BEGIN CERTIFICATE REQUEST-----\n".clean_csr($_REQUEST['CSR'])."-----END CERTIFICATE REQUEST-----\n";
if (($weakKey = checkWeakKeyCSR($csr)) !== "")
{
$id = 17;
showheader(_("My CAcert.org Account!"));
echo $weakKey;
showfooter();
exit;
}
$tmpfname = tempnam("/tmp", "id17CSR"); $tmpfname = tempnam("/tmp", "id17CSR");
$fp = fopen($tmpfname, "w"); $fp = fopen($tmpfname, "w");
fputs($fp, $csr); fputs($fp, $csr);
@ -1514,8 +1586,17 @@
printf(_("Invalid ID '%s' presented, can't do anything with it.")."<br>\n", $id); printf(_("Invalid ID '%s' presented, can't do anything with it.")."<br>\n", $id);
continue; continue;
} }
mysql_query("update `orgemailcerts` set `renewed`='1' where `id`='$id'");
$row = mysql_fetch_assoc($res); $row = mysql_fetch_assoc($res);
if (($weakKey = checkWeakKeyX509(file_get_contents(
$row['crt_name']))) !== "")
{
echo $weakKey, "<br/>\n";
continue;
}
mysql_query("update `orgemailcerts` set `renewed`='1' where `id`='$id'");
if($row['revoke'] > 0) if($row['revoke'] > 0)
{ {
printf(_("It would seem '%s' has already been revoked. I'll skip this for now.")."<br>\n", $row['CN']); printf(_("It would seem '%s' has already been revoked. I'll skip this for now.")."<br>\n", $row['CN']);
@ -1625,6 +1706,16 @@
if($process != "" && $oldid == 20) if($process != "" && $oldid == 20)
{ {
$CSR = clean_csr($_REQUEST['CSR']); $CSR = clean_csr($_REQUEST['CSR']);
if (($weakKey = checkWeakKeyCSR($CSR)) !== "")
{
$id = 20;
showheader(_("My CAcert.org Account!"));
echo $weakKey;
showfooter();
exit;
}
$_SESSION['_config']['tmpfname'] = tempnam("/tmp", "id20CSR"); $_SESSION['_config']['tmpfname'] = tempnam("/tmp", "id20CSR");
$fp = fopen($_SESSION['_config']['tmpfname'], "w"); $fp = fopen($_SESSION['_config']['tmpfname'], "w");
fputs($fp, $CSR); fputs($fp, $CSR);
@ -1675,6 +1766,23 @@
{ {
$id = 21; $id = 21;
if(!file_exists($_SESSION['_config']['tmpfname']))
{
showheader(_("My CAcert.org Account!"));
printf(_("Your certificate request has failed to be processed correctly, see %sthe WIKI page%s for reasons and solutions."), "<a href='http://wiki.cacert.org/wiki/FAQ/CertificateRenewal'>", "</a>");
showfooter();
exit;
}
if (($weakKey = checkWeakKeyCSR(file_get_contents(
$_SESSION['_config']['tmpfname']))) !== "")
{
showheader(_("My CAcert.org Account!"));
echo $weakKey;
showfooter();
exit;
}
if($_SESSION['_config']['0.CN'] == "" && $_SESSION['_config']['0.subjectAltName'] == "") if($_SESSION['_config']['0.CN'] == "" && $_SESSION['_config']['0.subjectAltName'] == "")
{ {
showheader(_("My CAcert.org Account!")); showheader(_("My CAcert.org Account!"));
@ -1799,8 +1907,17 @@
printf(_("Invalid ID '%s' presented, can't do anything with it.")."<br>\n", $id); printf(_("Invalid ID '%s' presented, can't do anything with it.")."<br>\n", $id);
continue; continue;
} }
mysql_query("update `orgdomaincerts` set `renewed`='1' where `id`='$id'");
$row = mysql_fetch_assoc($res); $row = mysql_fetch_assoc($res);
if (($weakKey = checkWeakKeyX509(file_get_contents(
$row['crt_name']))) !== "")
{
echo $weakKey, "<br/>\n";
continue;
}
mysql_query("update `orgdomaincerts` set `renewed`='1' where `id`='$id'");
if($row['revoke'] > 0) if($row['revoke'] > 0)
{ {
printf(_("It would seem '%s' has already been revoked. I'll skip this for now.")."<br>\n", $row['CN']); printf(_("It would seem '%s' has already been revoked. I'll skip this for now.")."<br>\n", $row['CN']);
@ -2498,6 +2615,14 @@
exit; exit;
} }
if (($weakKey = checkWeakKeyCSR($CSR)) !== "")
{
showheader(_("My CAcert.org Account!"));
echo $weakKey;
showfooter();
exit;
}
$query = "insert into `domaincerts` set $query = "insert into `domaincerts` set
`CN`='".$_SESSION['_config']['0.CN']."', `CN`='".$_SESSION['_config']['0.CN']."',
`domid`='".$_SESSION['_config']['row']['id']."', `domid`='".$_SESSION['_config']['row']['id']."',

357
includes/account_stuff.php
View file

@ -284,4 +284,361 @@ function hideall() {
</body> </body>
</html><? </html><?
} }
/**
* Produces a log entry with the error message with log level E_USER_WARN
* and a random ID an returns a message that can be displayed to the user
* including the generated ID
*
* @param $errormessage string
* The error message that should be logged
* @return string containing the generated ID that can be displayed to the
* user
*/
function failWithId($errormessage) {
$errorId = rand();
trigger_error("$errormessage. ID: $errorId", E_USER_WARNING);
return sprintf(_("Something went wrong when processing your request. ".
"Please contact %s for help and provide them with the ".
"following ID: %d"),
"<a href='mailto:support@cacert.org?subject=System%20Error%20-%20".
"ID%3A%20$errorId'>support@cacert.org</a>",
$errorId);
}
/**
* Checks whether the given CSR contains a vulnerable key
*
* @param $csr string
* The CSR to be checked
* @param $encoding string [optional]
* The encoding the CSR is in (for the "-inform" parameter of OpenSSL,
* currently only "PEM" (default) or "DER" allowed)
* @return string containing the reason if the key is considered weak,
* empty string otherwise
*/
function checkWeakKeyCSR($csr, $encoding = "PEM")
{
// non-PEM-encodings may be binary so don't use echo
$descriptorspec = array(
0 => array("pipe", "r"), // STDIN for child
1 => array("pipe", "w"), // STDOUT for child
);
$encoding = escapeshellarg($encoding);
$proc = proc_open("openssl req -inform $encoding -text -noout",
$descriptorspec, $pipes);
if (is_resource($proc))
{
fwrite($pipes[0], $csr);
fclose($pipes[0]);
$csrText = "";
while (!feof($pipes[1]))
{
$csrText .= fread($pipes[1], 8192);
}
fclose($pipes[1]);
if (($status = proc_close($proc)) !== 0 || $csrText === "")
{
return _("I didn't receive a valid Certificate Request, hit ".
"the back button and try again.");
}
} else {
return failWithId("checkWeakKeyCSR(): Failed to start OpenSSL");
}
return checkWeakKeyText($csrText);
}
/**
* Checks whether the given X509 certificate contains a vulnerable key
*
* @param $cert string
* The X509 certificate to be checked
* @param $encoding string [optional]
* The encoding the certificate is in (for the "-inform" parameter of
* OpenSSL, currently only "PEM" (default), "DER" or "NET" allowed)
* @return string containing the reason if the key is considered weak,
* empty string otherwise
*/
function checkWeakKeyX509($cert, $encoding = "PEM")
{
// non-PEM-encodings may be binary so don't use echo
$descriptorspec = array(
0 => array("pipe", "r"), // STDIN for child
1 => array("pipe", "w"), // STDOUT for child
);
$encoding = escapeshellarg($encoding);
$proc = proc_open("openssl x509 -inform $encoding -text -noout",
$descriptorspec, $pipes);
if (is_resource($proc))
{
fwrite($pipes[0], $cert);
fclose($pipes[0]);
$certText = "";
while (!feof($pipes[1]))
{
$certText .= fread($pipes[1], 8192);
}
fclose($pipes[1]);
if (($status = proc_close($proc)) !== 0 || $certText === "")
{
return _("I didn't receive a valid Certificate Request, hit ".
"the back button and try again.");
}
} else {
return failWithId("checkWeakKeyCSR(): Failed to start OpenSSL");
}
return checkWeakKeyText($certText);
}
/**
* Checks whether the given SPKAC contains a vulnerable key
*
* @param $spkac string
* The SPKAC to be checked
* @param $spkacname string [optional]
* The name of the variable that contains the SPKAC. The default is
* "SPKAC"
* @return string containing the reason if the key is considered weak,
* empty string otherwise
*/
function checkWeakKeySPKAC($spkac, $spkacname = "SPKAC")
{
/* Check for the debian OpenSSL vulnerability */
$spkac = escapeshellarg($spkac);
$spkacname = escapeshellarg($spkacname);
$spkacText = `echo $spkac | openssl spkac -spkac $spkacname`;
if ($spkacText === null) {
return _("I didn't receive a valid Certificate Request, hit the ".
"back button and try again.");
}
return checkWeakKeyText($spkacText);
}
/**
* Checks whether the given text representation of a CSR or a SPKAC contains
* a weak key
*
* @param $text string
* The text representation of a key as output by the
* "openssl <foo> -text -noout" commands
* @return string containing the reason if the key is considered weak,
* empty string otherwise
*/
function checkWeakKeyText($text)
{
/* Which public key algorithm? */
if (!preg_match('/^\s*Public Key Algorithm: ([^\s]+)$/m', $text,
$algorithm))
{
return failWithId("checkWeakKeyText(): Couldn't extract the ".
"public key algorithm used");
} else {
$algorithm = $algorithm[1];
}
if ($algorithm === "rsaEncryption")
{
if (!preg_match('/^\s*RSA Public Key: \((\d+) bit\)$/m', $text,
$keysize))
{
return failWithId("checkWeakKeyText(): Couldn't parse the RSA ".
"key size");
} else {
$keysize = intval($keysize[1]);
}
if ($keysize < 1024)
{
return sprintf(_("The keys that you use are very small ".
"and therefore insecure. Please generate stronger ".
"keys. More information about this issue can be ".
"found in %sthe wiki%s"),
"<a href='//wiki.cacert.org/WeakKeys#SmallKey'>",
"</a>");
} elseif ($keysize < 2048) {
// not critical but log so we have some statistics about
// affected users
trigger_error("checkWeakKeyText(): Certificate for small ".
"key (< 2048 bit) requested", E_USER_NOTICE);
}
$debianVuln = checkDebianVulnerability($text, $keysize);
if ($debianVuln === true)
{
return sprintf(_("The keys you use have very likely been ".
"generated with a vulnerable version of OpenSSL which ".
"was distributed by debian. Please generate new keys. ".
"More information about this issue can be found in ".
"%sthe wiki%s"),
"<a href='//wiki.cacert.org/WeakKeys#DebianVulnerability'>",
"</a>");
} elseif ($debianVuln === false) {
// not vulnerable => do nothing
} else {
return failWithId("checkWeakKeyText(): Something went wrong in".
"checkDebianVulnerability()");
}
if (!preg_match('/^\s*Exponent: (\d+) \(0x[0-9a-fA-F]+\)$/m', $text,
$exponent))
{
return failWithId("checkWeakKeyText(): Couldn't parse the RSA ".
"exponent");
} else {
$exponent = $exponent[1]; // exponent might be very big =>
//handle as string using bc*()
if (bccomp($exponent, "3") === 0)
{
return sprintf(_("The keys you use might be insecure. ".
"Although there is currently no known attack for ".
"reasonable encryption schemes, we're being ".
"cautious and don't allow certificates for such ".
"keys. Please generate stronger keys. More ".
"information about this issue can be found in ".
"%sthe wiki%s"),
"<a href='//wiki.cacert.org/WeakKeys#SmallExponent'>",
"</a>");
} elseif (!(bccomp($exponent, "65537") >= 0 &&
(bccomp($exponent, "100000") === -1 ||
// speed things up if way smaller than 2^256
bccomp($exponent, bcpow("2", "256")) === -1) )) {
// 65537 <= exponent < 2^256 recommended by NIST
// not critical but log so we have some statistics about
// affected users
trigger_error("checkWeakKeyText(): Certificate for ".
"unsuitable exponent '$exponent' requested",
E_USER_NOTICE);
}
}
}
/* No weakness found */
return "";
}
/**
* Reimplement the functionality of the openssl-vulnkey tool
*
* @param $text string
* The text representation of a key as output by the
* "openssl <foo> -text -noout" commands
* @param $keysize int [optional]
* If the key size is already known it can be provided so it doesn't
* have to be parsed again. This also skips the check whether the key
* is an RSA key => use wisely
* @return TRUE if key is vulnerable, FALSE otherwise, NULL in case of error
*/
function checkDebianVulnerability($text, $keysize = 0)
{
$keysize = intval($keysize);
if ($keysize === 0)
{
/* Which public key algorithm? */
if (!preg_match('/^\s*Public Key Algorithm: ([^\s]+)$/m', $text,
$algorithm))
{
trigger_error("checkDebianVulnerability(): Couldn't extract ".
"the public key algorithm used", E_USER_WARNING);
return null;
} else {
$algorithm = $algorithm[1];
}
if ($algorithm !== "rsaEncryption") return false;
/* Extract public key size */
if (!preg_match('/^\s*RSA Public Key: \((\d+) bit\)$/m', $text,
$keysize))
{
trigger_error("checkDebianVulnerability(): Couldn't parse the ".
"RSA key size", E_USER_WARNING);
return null;
} else {
$keysize = intval($keysize[1]);
}
}
// $keysize has been made sure to contain an int
$blacklist = "/usr/share/openssl-blacklist/blacklist.RSA-$keysize";
if (!(is_file($blacklist) && is_readable($blacklist)))
{
if (in_array($keysize, array(512, 1024, 2048, 4096)))
{
trigger_error("checkDebianVulnerability(): Blacklist for ".
"$keysize bit keys not accessible. Expected at ".
"$blacklist", E_USER_ERROR);
return null;
}
trigger_error("checkDebianVulnerability(): $blacklist is not ".
"readable. Unsupported key size?", E_USER_WARNING);
return false;
}
/* Extract RSA modulus */
if (!preg_match('/^\s*Modulus \(\d+ bit\):\n'.
'((?:\s*[0-9a-f][0-9a-f]:(?:\n)?)+[0-9a-f][0-9a-f])$/m',
$text, $modulus))
{
trigger_error("checkDebianVulnerability(): Couldn't extract the ".
"RSA modulus", E_USER_WARNING);
return null;
} else {
$modulus = $modulus[1];
// strip whitespace and colon leftovers
$modulus = str_replace(array(" ", "\t", "\n", ":"), "", $modulus);
// when using "openssl xxx -text" first byte was 00 in all my test
// cases but 00 not present in the "openssl xxx -modulus" output
if ($modulus[0] === "0" && $modulus[1] === "0")
{
$modulus = substr($modulus, 2);
} else {
trigger_error("checkDebianVulnerability(): First byte is not ".
"zero", E_USER_NOTICE);
}
$modulus = strtoupper($modulus);
}
/* calculate checksum and look it up in the blacklist */
$checksum = substr(sha1("Modulus=$modulus\n"), 20);
// $checksum and $blacklist should be safe, but just to make sure
$checksum = escapeshellarg($checksum);
$blacklist = escapeshellarg($blacklist);
exec("grep $checksum $blacklist", $dummy, $debianVuln);
if ($debianVuln === 0) // grep returned something => it is on the list
{
return true;
} elseif ($debianVuln === 1) { // grep returned nothing
return false;
} else {
trigger_error("checkDebianVulnerability(): Something went wrong ".
"when looking up the key with checksum $checksum in the ".
"blacklist $blacklist", E_USER_ERROR);
return null;
}
// Should not get here
return null;
}
?> ?>